Top 9 allergy friendly Magic Cookie Bars

If you’ve been missing out on magic cookie bars because of food allergies, I’ve got your back. These bars have all the rich, gooey layers you love—crumbly crust, melty chocolate, and sweet coconut—without the top common allergens that can make traditional recipes off-limits. The secret? We’re making our own quick, dairy-free sweetened condensed milk, so you can skip the cans and control exactly what goes in. The result is pure dessert magic: chewy, decadent, and safe for everyone at the table.

I used oat milk to make the sweetened condensed milk. But you can use any favorite non dairy milk.

If you need an allergy safe graham cracker, partake is a top 9 free brand. You could really use any allergy safe cookie crumbs for the crust! :)

I recommend enjoy life chocolate chips!

If you’d prefer a store bought sweetened condensed milk, they do make vegan sweetened condensed milks! I have found some at Sprouts and Walmart. It’s usually made from coconut milk.

***IMPORTANT- the recipe for homemade sweetened condensed milk will make more than you need! Only pour enough of it over the graham crust to cover it. You will likely have some left over :)***